Why our brains get big numbers wrong (and how to play better)
Why do we get it wrong so often in a comparison game, even on topics we think we know? Because our brains are not built to handle numbers that are very large or far from our experience. Psychologists have described several mechanisms behind these mistakes. Knowing them helps you play better — and read the news better.
1. A million, a billion: it all sounds the same
Beyond a few thousand, big numbers become abstract. “A million” and “a billion” sound like two ways of saying “an awful lot”, although they differ by a factor of a thousand.
A concrete benchmark: a million seconds is about 11 and a half days. A billion seconds is about 31 years and 8 months.
Research in numerical cognition shows that, spontaneously, we perceive quantities in a rather logarithmic way: the difference between 1 and 10 feels as big as between 10 and 100. That is handy in everyday life, but it squashes the gaps between big numbers. In Comparo, it is the trap of followers and streams: 400 million and 4 billion feel “about the same”, whereas one is ten times the other.
The tip: count the zeros, or bring everything to the same unit (“0.4 billion versus 4 billion”).
2. Anchoring: the first number sticks
In the 1970s, psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman showed that a number seen just before an estimate pulls the estimate towards it, even when the number is unrelated. This is the anchoring effect.
In a game, it carries over from one question to the next: after seeing “5.6 billion streams”, we tend to overestimate the next song. In Chain mode, the champion’s value serves as an anchor, and that helps; in VS mode, it can mislead.
The tip: treat each duel as a fresh question, except in Chain mode where the champion really does stay.
3. “Bigger means stronger”
Our intuition links size to power, speed and longevity. It is often right… which is exactly why it betrays us when it is wrong:
- A 50 kg cheetah runs far faster than a six-tonne elephant, but the elephant (≈ 40 km/h) runs almost as fast as Usain Bolt.
- A 250 kg giant tortoise outlives the elephant.
- Gigantic Saturn has a surface gravity barely higher than Earth’s.
Comparo deliberately picks these “trap” duels, where the lighter one wins.
The tip: ask yourself what the question really measures. Speed depends on body shape, longevity on metabolism, gravity on radius as much as mass.
4. Famous doesn’t mean “more”
We often judge by availability: what comes to mind easily seems more important. A star who is everywhere in our media must surely have more followers, a heavily promoted song more streams.
Yet audience records are often held by publics we rarely see: footballers followed worldwide, Indian channels, children’s programmes, creators born on a platform. See our article on social media giants.
The tip: think about the size of the target audience, not your own exposure.
5. Reputation versus serving
“Espresso is the strongest coffee”, “Red Bull is a caffeine bomb”… These reputations are true per millilitre but false per serving: a 250 ml can of Red Bull contains about 80 mg of caffeine, less than a large cup of filter coffee (≈ 95 mg). See our caffeine guide.
The tip: always read the unit and the serving shown under the answer.
6. Time distorts dates
For dates, we compress the distant past: two medieval events seem contemporary to us, although they may be centuries apart. Conversely, we often overestimate how old the things of our childhood are. That is why Comparo measures the difficulty of date questions in years of difference, not in a simple ratio.
The tip: reason by era (before or after a revolution, a war, the arrival of the internet), then refine.
In short
| Bias | Typical trap | Reflex |
|---|---|---|
| Logarithmic scale | million ≈ billion | count the zeros |
| Anchoring | the previous number sways you | start from scratch |
| “Bigger means stronger” | elephant vs cheetah | ask what is measured |
| Availability | the most visible star | think of the global audience |
| Reputation | espresso, Red Bull | read the serving |
| Time compression | old dates | reason by era |
No player escapes these biases completely: that is what makes comparisons fun. But knowing them turns a game of chance into real reasoning.





