Why our brain gets orders of magnitude wrong

A million seconds is about eleven and a half days. A billion seconds is almost 32 years. Most people know both words, but few realise that the gap between them is the same as between a week and a half and an adult lifetime. That is the core difficulty of Comparo: as soon as numbers get big, our intuition loses its bearings.

A ruler marked… on a logarithmic scale

Research in cognitive psychology, notably by French scientist Stanislas Dehaene, has shown that our “number sense” does not work like an evenly marked ruler. Left to ourselves, we place numbers on a compressed scale: the gap between 1 and 10 feels as big as the gap between 10 and 100, or between 100 and 1,000.

Children show this very clearly. Asked to place 10 on a line running from 0 to 100, the youngest often put it far too far to the right, as if small numbers took up more space than large ones. School teaches us the linear scale for familiar numbers, but as soon as we leave our comfort zone (millions, billions, distant years), the logarithmic reflex comes back.

The direct consequence in the game: a gap from 1 to 3 impresses us more than a gap from 1,000 to 3,000, even though it is exactly the same ratio.

Weber’s law: we perceive ratios, not differences

In the 19th century, physiologists Ernst Weber and Gustav Fechner observed that our senses perceive changes in proportion to the starting value. Adding 1 kg to a 2 kg bag is felt immediately; adding 1 kg to a 20 kg bag barely registers.

That is why the game measures a question’s difficulty by the ratio between the two values, not their difference. Comparing 100 and 150, or 10,000 and 15,000, is the same level of difficulty. And that is why a very close pair (a ratio of 1.2) is a real challenge, even between two familiar objects.

Anchoring: the first number you see skews the rest

In 1974, psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman described the anchoring effect: an estimate is strongly influenced by a number seen just before, even an unrelated one. In their experiments, a rigged wheel of fortune was enough to shift participants’ answers to geography questions.

In the game, anchoring is in full swing. After a question about 500-metre skyscrapers, a 300-metre tower looks small. After a question about ants, a cat looks huge. The best players are wary of the previous question and start again from their own reference points.

The availability heuristic: the spectacular seems bigger

Another idea from Tversky and Kahneman: we judge how frequent or important something is by how easily it comes to mind. What is spectacular, heavily covered or frightening seems bigger, faster or more common.

The great white shark seems enormous because it is famous; it is in fact far smaller than the whale shark. The Titanic seems fast because it is huge and legendary; Usain Bolt beats it at top speed. The megalodon seems heavier than the blue whale because it is mysterious; it is the other way round.

The size-weight illusion, and its cousins

In 1891, French physician Augustin Charpentier described a striking illusion: of two objects of the same weight, the smaller one feels heavier when you lift them. Our brain expects the big object to be heavier, and overcorrects.

Illusions of this kind affect every comparison. A big object seems heavy, a heavy object seems slow, an old object seems small. These are usual correlations that our brain applies by default, and that comparisons across different worlds (a bird against a cheetah, a moon against a planet) turn upside down.

How to estimate better

Research on estimation (sometimes called “Fermi problems”, after physicist Enrico Fermi, who loved asking them) offers a few simple methods:

  1. Keep fixed reference points. A person is about 1.7 m tall and weighs 70 kg; a car weighs about a tonne and a half; the Eiffel Tower is 330 m tall. Comparing with a reference is far more reliable than guessing in a vacuum.
  2. Think in orders of magnitude. Before looking for the exact figure, ask: tens, hundreds, thousands? Most serious mistakes are order-of-magnitude mistakes.
  3. Separate the real question from the impression. “Which is more impressive?” is not “which is heavier?”. Rephrasing the question under your breath often helps.
  4. Think about how it was measured. A speed in a dive, the weight of an adult male, a height including the antenna: the detail under the card sometimes changes everything.

Why it matters beyond the game

Being able to estimate orders of magnitude helps every day: reading a public budget expressed in billions, understanding a medical statistic, judging a claim about speed or power. Comparo was designed as a playful workout for that skill: every answer reveals the true value and the gap, and it is by getting things wrong that you recalibrate your reference points.

More articles

Pick a mode